War on Word: Low-cost and free office suites may delete Microsoft dominance

08/01/2002

By Doug Bedell / The Dallas Morning News

At $479, the full version of Microsoft's Office XP Standard edition now surpasses what some users paid for their entire home computer systems.

Even upgrading from Office 97 carries a price tag – $279 – that might cripple a household's tech budget.

Until recently, few free or low-cost software programs offered dependable alternatives to the Microsoft productivity suite, which dominates the world's computer desktops.

Alternative programs didn't allow users to accurately view PowerPoint, Excel and Word files arriving from the outside world. Worse, they often badly mangled files during attempts to store creations in the .doc, .ppt or .xls formats.

GETTING WITH THE PROGRAMS
Users will find that alternatives to Microsoft's Office vary from a low-cost program with some bells and whistles down to a stripped-down free offering that provides the basics.

OpenOffice 1.0
Cost: Free
Publisher: CollabNet and OpenOffice open source development community with source code from Sun Microsystems
Download site: OpenOffice.org
Operating System: Windows 95/98/Me/NT/2000/XP, Linux, PPC Linux, Solaris and others; Apple OS X developers "pre-alpha" edition available
Download size: 50 megabytes
Minimum hard drive space: 250MB
Minimum processor type: Intel Pentium or equivalent
Minimum RAM size: For the Windows version, 64MB
Includes: Writer word processor program, Calc spreadsheet program, Draw graphics program, Impress presentation program
Can open and save in: Microsoft Word and Excel 9x/2000/XP
Missing: WordPerfect compatibility, e-mail and personal information manager

StarOffice 6.0
Cost: $75.95
Publisher: CollabNet and OpenOffice open source development community with source code from Sun Microsystems
Download site: www.sun.com; also sold on CD
Operating System: Windows 95/98/Me/NT/2000/XP, Linux, PPC Linux, Solaris and others; Apple OS X developers "pre-alpha" edition available
Download size: Up to 121 megabytes, depending on operating system
Minimum hard drive space: 250MB
Minimum processor type: Intel Pentium or equivalent
Minimum RAM size: For the Windows version, 64MB
Includes: Writer word processor program with spell-checker and thesaurus, Calc spreadsheet program, Draw graphics program, Impress presentation program, Adabas D database program. Also includes setup and user guides, extensive clip art gallery, extra fonts and certificate for one free tech support call
Can open and save in: Microsoft Word, WordPerfect and Excel 9x/2000/XP
Missing: E-mail and personal information manager

602Pro PC Suite 2001
Cost: Free
Publisher: Software602
Download site: Software602.com
Operating system: Windows 95/98/ME/NT4/2000/XP
Download size: 13 megabytes
Minimum hard drive space: 40MB
Minimum processor type: Intel Pentium
Minimum RAM size: 16MB
Includes: 602Text word processor, 602Tab spreadsheet program, 602Photo graphics editor (designed for digital camera and scanner image editing) and 602Album digital photo organizer Can open and save in: Microsoft Word and Excel 9x/2000/XP
Missing: WordPerfect compatibility, a PowerPoint equivalent, e-mail and personal information manager

That's changing.

In May, Sun Microsystems released its StarOffice suite in a free version that provides compelling features for those wanting to sidestep endless Microsoft upgrades.

Meanwhile, Czech programmers at Software602 Inc. are refining their free creation, 602Pro PC Suite 2001, to enhance interoperability with Word and Excel files.

Everyday computing

The Sun and Software602 packages may not meet the needs of Office power users – those who depend on elaborate macro stunts and flawless production of Excel charts and graphs. And those who require a lot of handholding via software support calls will find neither enticing.

But for common, everyday word processing, spreadsheet and other basic needs, these two products are hard to ignore.

Right now, most of the buzz in the tech world surrounds Sun's bold attack on Microsoft's dominance. Sun opened its source code to more than 50,000 developers, who donated their time and collaborated for 18 months to produce OpenOffice 1.0.

Available as a free download at OpenOffice .org, it is essentially the same base product that Sun now sells as StarOffice 6.0 ($75.95 at Sun.com). Buying the StarOffice version will get consumers a setup guide and user's guide, plus a certificate for one free call to the company's support center. It also contains a more robust spell-checker, a database program, an extensive clip art gallery and more fonts.

But many users may find OpenOffice 1.0 is all they need.

This 50-megabyte download package opens and accurately renders most Microsoft Office formats, then allows users to save them in the same form. The Writer portion of the suite has the form and function familiar to anyone raised on Word.

OpenOffice's Excel equivalent, Calc, can produce up to 256 worksheets per file with all the bells and whistles that most users require.

Its answer to PowerPoint – Impress – boasts similar transitions and special effects.

For its word processing program, where most users spend the bulk of their time, OpenOffice borrows from WordPerfect's design with a vertical tool bar that holds shortcuts.

About the only thing OpenOffice 1.0 doesn't offer is an equivalent to Office's Outlook e-mail and personal information manager. Other drawbacks: The spell-checking and thesaurus features won't impress some users. Unlike StarOffice 6.0, it won't work with WordPerfect files.

Versions are currently available for Windows, Linux and Solaris operating systems, and an early "developers version" for Mac OS X recently sprang to life.

Business slant

While the OpenOffice program will remain free, Sun is banking that businesses will flock to its StarOffice 6.0 as licensing requirements for Microsoft Office grow more onerous. Corporations with a large number of computers running Office are being forced to buy a new software maintenance plan by July 31 or face higher prices for upgrades.

As a result, more than 1 million downloads of StarOffice 6.0 were made during the short period that Sun offered it for free, says Nancy Lee, group product marketing manager.

At OpenOffice.org, curious users jammed the Web servers, downloading the free version more than 4.5 million times in the opening days of its availability in May.

"We've already had a huge start," Ms. Lee says. "People are finding they just don't need all the bells and whistles to get their work done."

Eric Raymond, co-founder of the Open Source Initiative, says, "OpenOffice.org 1.0 may be the single best hope for consumers fed up with Microsoft's desktop monopoly."

Czech offering

Named for a Czechoslovakian software club in the 1980s, Software602's 602Pro PC Suite 2001 is a slimmer productivity suite that includes a basic word processor and spreadsheet program.

Currently available at Software602.com, this free, 13-megabyte download works only in Windows 98 and higher versions. The company makes money by selling $30 to $50 add-ons such as a thesaurus or mail merge.

Its word processor, 602Text, is capable of opening and saving in most Microsoft Word version formats. Although stripped to its basics, it contains all the standard tools needed to turn out professional-looking documents.

Edit tracking allows users to see changes made by others when collaborating, just as in Word. And a "format brush" is handy for duplicating text display styles. Tool bars are customizable and flexible. One useful option even displays a word count, line count and other important document information.

The spreadsheet component, 602Tab, doesn't do macros and has a limited number of chart styles available. And if you want support, the company will charge you for calls, which can be placed only during an eight-hour window every day.

Either OpenOffice 1.0 or 602Pro PC Suite may prove ideal for that extra computer in the house. Both are easy to install, require a minimum of disk space and are simple to learn.

And, best of all, the price is right.